In Reply to: Re: For me it bounces between Animals and Wish You Were Here posted by TheHappyBurgermeister on September 17, 2025 at 12:58:12
The thing to me about Wish You Were Here is how it plays as an album. If you play a song here or a song there, well maybe I think Pigs is better or Time is better but in terms of a straight play through and a concept, WYWH is so complete, and so well composed. I also like Shine On a lot. I grew up playing vinyl and that was a record I always flipped to play the other side.
Again, I think the trilogy of Moon-Wish-Animals is an amazing set and accomplishment. We're basically counting angels on the head of pin trying to say which one is best.